Best Thermostat Setting for Winter: 4 Proven Modesto Rules

The best thermostat setting for winter in a Modesto home is 68 degrees while you are home and awake, lower while asleep or away, with one large exception: on a heat pump, a deep setback costs more than it saves. This guide gives the numbers, the reasons, and the schedule for each kind of system.

What temperature should I set in winter?

Two of the largest HVAC manufacturers’ consumer guides land on the same figure. Trane writes that according to ENERGY STAR the magic number for a winter thermostat setting is 68 degrees when you are at home (Trane). HVAC.com: “The best average house temperature in winter is 68 degrees while you’re at home,” with a recommendation of around 60 degrees while away or asleep (HVAC.com). Neither number is a law. Sixty-eight is the point where most households stop noticing the cold in a sweater, and every degree above it is a choice with a price.

The price is set by the gap between inside and outside. A house loses heat in proportion to that gap, so a thermostat at 72 on a 40-degree night asks the system to replace a 32-degree difference, and one at 68 asks for 28. That is roughly an eighth less heat to make, before any setback at all.

Does turning it down at night save money?

On a furnace, yes, and the Department of Energy’s figure is the one everyone quotes. Its guidance is to set it lower by 7 to 10 degrees for 8 hours a day while you are away or asleep, and “doing so can shave as much as 10% per year off your heating bills” (DOE). The same figure appears on the DOE’s home upgrades page: you can save as much as 10 percent a year on heating and cooling by turning the thermostat back 7 to 10 degrees (DOE Energy Saver).

The reason it works is the same gap. A house at 60 overnight loses heat more slowly than one at 68, so the furnace runs fewer hours through the night, and the morning recovery costs less than those hours saved. The common objection, that the furnace “works harder” to recover, is wrong for a furnace: it runs at the same output for a longer single cycle, and the total is still less than holding 68 all night. The objection is right for a heat pump, which is the next section.

System Home and awake Asleep Away for the day Away for days
Gas furnace 68 60 to 62 58 to 60 55
Heat pump, standard thermostat 68 66 66 60, and expect strips on return
Heat pump, heat-pump thermostat 68 64 to 66, ramped 64 to 66, ramped 58 to 60, ramped
Any system, vulnerable person at home 68 to 70 66 n/a n/a

The furnace row follows the DOE’s 7 to 10 degree range. The heat pump rows are narrower on purpose, for the reason below. The last row is not an efficiency setting; an infant, an older adult or someone unwell needs the house held warmer, and the bill is secondary.

Why is setback different for a heat pump?

Because of what happens at 6am. A heat pump moves heat slowly and steadily, and when the thermostat asks for a six or eight degree climb all at once, the system reads the gap as the heat pump failing and switches on its electric resistance strips to close it. Carrier states the mechanism plainly: recovering that heat in the morning often forces the auxiliary heat to turn on (Carrier). Those strips are 100 percent efficient against a heat pump that can be 300 percent, and Google’s Nest guidance puts their cost at about 2 to 5 times the heat pump’s (Google Nest Help). An hour of strips in the morning can erase a night of savings.

The Department of Energy says so in its own words: programmable thermostats have generally not been recommended for heat pump systems, though some newer models now work with them (DOE Energy Saver). Those newer models are the heat-pump thermostats: they ramp the temperature up slowly ahead of the scheduled time so the heat pump can climb on its own, and they let you set a lockout temperature below which the strips are allowed and above which they are not. Nest calls its version Heat Pump Balance and sets the lockout between a Max Savings and a Max Comfort point; other brands expose a threshold setting that does the same job. With one of those, a modest setback works. With a standard thermostat, the safe rule on a heat pump is two degrees, not eight. What auxiliary heat is and how to keep it off is covered in the guide to auxiliary and emergency heat and why they spike the bill, and how a heat pump behaves in cold weather in the guide to a heat pump not heating.

If the heat pump runs on its strips for hours every morning no matter how small the setback, the thermostat is not the fault. A heat pump that cannot recover two degrees on its own in a valley winter is undersized, low on charge or failing, and that is a heat pump repair diagnosis rather than a settings question.

What does the Modesto winter change?

Two things. The season is short and the nights are mild, which changes the arithmetic of setback in opposite directions. Heating demand here, measured in heating degree days from the NOAA 1991 to 2020 normals for the Modesto airport station, is almost nothing in October at 67.5, jumps to 318 in November, peaks across December and January at around 545 in December, and falls back through February at 364 and March at 262 (NOAA normals). So the best thermostat setting for winter here matters most across about three months, and a schedule that is wrong in December costs more than one that is wrong in March.

The mild nights are the other half. With an average December low near 39 degrees, a house set back to 60 overnight often never reaches 60 before morning, which means the furnace simply does not run, and that is the whole point. On a heat pump the same mild nights mean the outdoor unit still has plenty of heat to draw on, so a small setback recovers easily without the strips, and the balance point rarely arrives. Modesto is a good climate for a heat pump and a bad one for a deep heat pump setback, at the same time.

On the electric side, the Modesto Irrigation District’s residential Schedule D charges $0.15279 per kWh for the first 500 kWh in winter against $0.17759 in summer, so the winter price is lower and the whole winter bill is volume (MID Schedule D). A setback that keeps the strips off is the single largest lever a heat pump home has on that volume. Reading the bill itself, therms and kilowatt-hours against last year, is in why a heating bill is so high.

Best thermostat setting for winter, by hour?

Here is the best thermostat setting for winter laid out as a weekday for the two common systems, with Modesto’s early sunrise and mild afternoons in mind.

  1. Furnace. 68 from 6am to 8am. 60 from 8am to 5pm if the house is empty, 66 if someone works from home. 68 from 5pm to 10pm. 61 overnight. Set the morning period to begin 30 minutes before anyone gets up; a furnace recovers a 7-degree setback in well under an hour in this climate.
  2. Heat pump with a heat-pump thermostat. 68 by 6:30am, with the thermostat’s early-start or ramp feature on so it begins climbing at 5am on the heat pump alone. 65 during an empty day. 68 by 5pm. 65 overnight. Set the lockout or balance point so the strips are not allowed above about 40 degrees outside, which here is most nights.
  3. Heat pump with a standard thermostat. Hold 68 by day and 66 at night, and raise the setpoint one degree at a time, never four, when you want it warmer. Lennox’s threshold for concern is AUX running more than about 30 minutes at a stretch (Lennox); if a two-degree recovery triggers that, get the system checked rather than the schedule.
  4. Away for a weekend. Furnace: 55. Heat pump: 60, and accept that the strips may run for a while when you turn it back up, or raise it in steps across the evening you return.

Does the thermostat’s location matter?

More than the number on it. ENERGY STAR’s guidance is to “install your thermostat away from heating or cooling registers, appliances, lighting, doorways, fireplaces, skylights and windows, and areas that receive direct sunlight or drafts,” adding that “interior walls are best” (ENERGY STAR). A thermostat in afternoon sun reads warm and lets the house cool. One beside a supply register satisfies itself in minutes and short cycles the system. One in a closed hallway holds 68 in the hallway and 64 in the bedrooms. In each case the setting is right and the house is wrong, and no schedule fixes it.

When should you call a professional?

The safety line first. A gas smell means leave the house and call 911 from outside, then the gas utility. A carbon monoxide alarm means the same. No thermostat setting has anything to do with either, and both override this page.

Call when a heat pump runs its strips for long stretches on mild nights whatever the setback, when the system short cycles at every setting, when the house cannot reach 68 on a normal winter day, or when you want a heat-pump thermostat wired in with a C wire and the balance point set properly. The schedule is yours. The lockout temperature, the staging and the wiring are a technician’s, and in Modesto they are a short visit.

Frequently asked questions

What temperature should I set my thermostat to in winter?

Sixty-eight degrees while home and awake is the figure both Trane and HVAC.com attribute to ENERGY STAR, with a lower setting asleep or away. On a furnace, 60 to 62 overnight. On a heat pump, 65 to 66, because a deeper setback brings the electric strips on in the morning.

Does turning the thermostat down at night save money?

On a furnace, yes. The DOE puts a 7 to 10 degree setback for eight hours a day at up to 10 percent off annual heating bills. On a heat pump with a standard thermostat, a setback that size usually costs more than it saves, because the morning recovery runs on resistance strips at two to five times the heat pump’s cost.

Why is setback different for a heat pump?

A heat pump recovers slowly, and when the thermostat sees a large gap it calls the auxiliary strips to close it. Carrier describes the morning recovery as the usual trigger. A heat-pump thermostat that ramps up early and locks the strips out above a set outdoor temperature makes a modest setback work; a standard thermostat does not.

Is 72 degrees too high for winter?

It is a comfort choice with a cost. Each degree above 68 widens the gap between inside and outside that the system has to replace, so on a 40-degree Modesto night 72 asks for about an eighth more heat than 68. If someone vulnerable is at home, hold it; if not, try 68 in a sweater for a week.

What is the best thermostat setting for winter when nobody is home?

On a furnace, 58 to 60 for a working day and 55 for a trip. On a heat pump, 65 to 66 for the day and 60 for a trip, raised in steps on return so the strips do not carry the whole recovery.

The short version

Sixty-eight awake, lower asleep and away. On a furnace, go down 7 to 10 degrees and take the DOE’s 10 percent. On a heat pump, go down two degrees with a standard thermostat, or get a heat-pump thermostat with early start and a lockout and go down five. Put the thermostat on an interior wall out of the sun. And if the strips run anyway, the problem is the heat pump, not the schedule.